Mcnamaras commentary about his involvement in, among other things, world war ii and the vietnamese war, i was shocked to hear him say that before the dropping of the atomic bombs on hiroshima and nagasaki in 1945, under the command of general curtis lemay, united states b29. The operation meetinghouse firebombing of tokyo on the night of march 910, 1945, was the single deadliest air raid in history. This attack was codenamed operation meetinghouse by the usaaf and is known as the great tokyo air raid in japan. Hersey details the lives and actions of six residents of the hiroshima, starting immediately prior to the dropping of the bomb on august 6, 1945 and moving up all the way through the mid1980s. Lesson the firebombing of tokyo stanford university. In the space of a few hours, they dropped 1,667 tons of napalmfilled incendiary bombs on the japanese capital, killing more than 100,000 people in a single strike, and injuring several times that number. But while the japanese public and the world rightly remember hiroshima as a living symbol of the horrors of nuclear war, the tokyo firebombing is generally regarded as a footnote in any. On the night of 910 march 1945, operation meetinghouse was conducted and is regarded as the single most destructive bombing raid in human history. Survivors beg japan to remember the forgotten 100,000.
As historian john dower described in his 1986 book war without. The bombing of tokyo, tokyodaikushu was a series of firebombing air raids by the united states army air forces during the pacific campaigns of world war ii. Its well done but in personalizing the stories it has often lead people to overdramatize or exaggerate some aspects of what happened. The committee for the compilation of materials on damage caused by the atomic bombs in hiroshima and nagasaki, hiroshima and nagasaki. Even before the hiroshima nagasaki bombing, american air force general curtis lemay boasted that american bombers were driving them japanese back to the stone age. Aug 08, 2005 tokyo firebombing killed many more people than did the bombing of hiroshima and nagasaki. Like mission to berlin, mission to tokyo is an excellent book of recollections of those who took part in the bombing of japan and the final chapter tells of the atomic bombs dropped on hiroshima and nagasaki who devastated both cities and caused many casualties which forced japan to surrender. The great tokyo air raid and the bombing of civilians in world war ii. On the night of 910 march 1945, the united states army air forces usaaf conducted a. Mar 06, 2020 firebombing of tokyo on the night of march 9, 1945, u. The atomic bombs of hiroshima and nagasaki have dominated the retelling of wwii history, but as a single attack the bombing of tokyo in march 1945 was more destructive. The firebombing that night and morning left 25% of tokyo charred, with the damage spread out over 20 miles of the metropolis. Nagaski recalled for paul hamm in his book hiroshima nagasaki.
As explained in the history of the bombings, the united states created a set of nuclear bombs that were dropped on hiroshima and nagasaki only 6 months after severe firebombing of japans largest and most populated cities. Mar 10, 2005 the tokyo firebombing has long been overshadowed by the u. Charred remains of japanese civilians after the firebombing of tokyo. W hen the united states launched a bombing operation over japan on mar. The firebombing of tokyo audiobook by charles river editors. Were firebombing and other conventional bombing techniques. Aerial photo of tokyo after the bombing of march 910. In 2018, fewer than 10,000 people, including groups of schoolchildren, visited the tokyo center, compared with the more than 1. On the night of 910 march 1945, the united states army air forces usaaf conducted a devastating firebombing raid on tokyo, the japanese capital city. American fire bombing and atomic bombing of japan in history. The mass graves under the cherry blossom 70 years on, the fire bombing of tokyo remains the deadliest bombing campaign in history survivors commute near an incendiary bombed. The fire bombing of japan, march 9 august 15, 1945. Three days later, a second us atomic bomb killed 70,000 people in nagasaki.
Pearl harbor or no pearl harbor, the bombing of tokyo on august 14, 1945, was a despicable act worse than the firebombing of tokyo, worse than hiroshima, and worse than nagasaki because it was so unnecessary. Yet it remains one of the forgotten horrors of the second world war. Mar 09, 2020 but while the japanese public and the world rightly remember hiroshima as a living symbol of the horrors of nuclear war, the tokyo firebombing is generally regarded as a footnote in any. The fire bombing of japan, march 9 august 15, 1945 hoyt, edwin p. More than 2,700 people were killed and 8,000 injured. Although most casualties of the tokyo firebombing were civilians, they are not the. The firebombing of tokyo on march 9, 1945 marked the beginning of the end for imperial japan. It took the firebombing of tokyo, and then a somewhat proportional disaster in hiroshima, then nagasaki, until the japanese govt realized there was no winning game plan. Pope francis is in japan for a threeday visiting nagasaki, hiroshima, and tokyo to bring an antinuclear message and pray for. Japanese students create vr experience of hiroshima bombing. After the war, while hiroshima and nagasaki became symbols of japans suffering and the peace movement, the great tokyo air raid was virtually excluded from public discourse. The firebombing of tokyo continues on march 10, 1945, 300 american bombers continue to drop almost 2,000 tons of incendiaries on tokyo, japan, in a mission that launched the previous day. The atomic bombing of hiroshima killed less japanese civilians than the firebombing of tokyo a few weeks earlier.
Atomic bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki wikipedia. Americas 1945 attack on japans capital remains undeservedly obscure alongside hiroshima and nagasaki. The man who wont let the world forget the firebombing of tokyo. Narrated by richard baseheart and produced by david l. All in all, the three disasters most likely saved more japanese lives than they took. The deadliest air raid in history the firebombing of tokyo on march 9, 1945 marked the beginning of the end for imperial japan. Tokyo was considered for targeting but there was no strategic value seen in doing so. Today marks the seventieth anniversary of the american firebombing of tokyo, world war iis deadliest day. Firebombing of tokyo on the night of march 9, 1945, u. The great tokyo air raid and the bombing of civilians in. The following article on the firebombing of tokyo is an excerpt from warren kozaks curtis lemay.
Jun 15, 2016 since translating the great tokyo air raid in 2014, excerpted in saotome katsumoto and the firebombing of tokyo, he has been researching the tokyo air raids. His article on us bombing strategy appeared in the japanese journal kushu tsushin air raid report. The march 1945 firebombing of tokyo and the immorality of. Wolper, ten seconds that shook the world is a factual and chronological account of the events preceding the atomic bombing of hiroshima. Explain that while the atomic bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki are wellknown events of world war ii, the firebombing of tokyo is hardly known even though many consider it to be the deadliest conventional air raid in history. He stayed on after war broke in europe and was trapped in the country after japans attack on pearl harbor. August 07, 2015 information clearing house jacobin august 06, 2015 today marks the seventieth anniversary of the american firebombing of tokyo, world war iis deadliest day. Saotome said he understood that hiroshima was unique in that it represented the first time nuclear bombs were used anywhere in the world. Pope francis lays a wreath for the victims of the atomic bombing at hiroshima peace memorial park. Hiroshima and nagasaki are not fertile grounds for a farmers dream seeds. Over the course of the bombing raid, american planes dropped an estimated 2,000 tons of explosives on the city, creating a massive firestorm which killed countless numbers of civilians. Whats the best historynon fiction book on the bombing of dresden. Along with pictures of important people, places, and events, you will learn about the firebombing of tokyo like never before, in no time at all.
The firebombing of tokyo on march 9, 1945 marked the beginning of the end. Firebombing is one of the cruelest ways to attack a city. Mar, 2020 but while the japanese public and the world rightly remember hiroshima as a living symbol of the horrors of nuclear war, the tokyo firebombing is generally regarded as a footnote. Tokyo wwii firebombing, the single most deadly bombing. Dec 01, 2016 this article has reflected on the political dynamics that lie behind the differential treatment of the firebombing and atomic bombing of japan in both japan and the united states, events that brought disaster to the japanese nation, but also contributed to ending a bitter war and paved the way for the rebirth of a japan stripped of its empire. Robert guillain was a french reporter assigned to japan who was trapped in the country after japans attack on pearl harbor. The firebombing of tokyo on the night of march 910, 1945 touched off the wave of firebombing that destroyed 64 japanese cities and culminated in the atomic bombing of hiroshima and nagasaki. Strategic bombing survey, field report covering air raid protection and allied subjects tokyo n. The deadliest air raid in history daily planet air. Why, then, is the atom bombing demonized when the march 9, 1945, firebombing of tokyo, which killed 85,000 japanese in one night, is not. More people were killed in the tokyo firebombing of march 910 than in the atomic bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki five months later. Bombs dropped from 279 boeing b29 superfortress heavy bombers burned out much of eastern tokyo. Aug 12, 2015 the nuclear attacks on hiroshima and nagasaki and the firebombing of tokyo.
Aerial shots of bombed mitsubishi aircraft plant at nagoya near tokyo. Most books about the final phase of the pacific war detail the firebombing of japanese cities, raise questions concerning dropping the atomic bombs on hiroshima and nagasaki, or participate in a debate whether u. The bombing of tokyo, often referred to as a firebombing, was conducted as part of the air raids on japan by theunited states army air forces during the pacific campaigns of world war ii. Firebombing raids on tokyo during the night of march 910. List of books and articles about hiroshima and nagasaki. Hiroshima, the famous account written by john hersey for the new yorker, had a. But few in the united states are aware that the attack even took place. Air forces most controversial bombing campaign of world war ii chronicles the background of the campaign, its destruction, and its notorious legacy. Dan carlins hardcore history episode about the atomic bomb goes into very great detail about how hiroshima and nagasaki were just the end of a progression that very much included the firebombings of dresden and tokyo and others.
Since the setting is the title of the book, you probably got the memo that this subject is kind of a big deal. Historys deadliest air raid happened in tokyo during. Anniversary of firebombing raid on tokyo march 10, 1945 leo. Whats the best historynonfiction book on the bombing of. Not every environment accepts the dream shaping progress you want to put across. In fact, the damage was so extensive that casualty counts range by over 100,000. Bombing of tokyo, march 910, 1945, firebombing raid codenamed operation meetinghouse by the united states on the capital of japan during the final stages of world war ii, often cited as one of the most destructive acts of war in history, more destructive than the bombing of dresden, hiroshima, or nagasaki. What was cheaper the fire bombing of tokyo or the bombing. In his 1968 book, reprinted in 1990, historian gabriel kolko cited a figure of 125,000 deaths. Mar 11, 2015 more people were killed in the indiscriminate firebombing of march 10 than in the immediate aftermath of the dropping of the atomic bomb on hiroshima. This raid, known as operation meetinghouse, caused incredible destruction, killing.
By dawn, more than 100,000 people were dead, a million were homeless, and 40 square kilometers of tokyo were burned to the ground. Specifically, an unprecedented level of destruction befell tokyo in midmarch 1945 and would continue through the bombings of hiroshima on aug. The atomic bombing of hiroshima killed less japanese civilians than the fire bombing of tokyo a few weeks earlier. The atomic bombs of hiroshima and nagasaki have dominated the retelling of wwii history, but as a single attack the bombing of tokyo in.
An eyewitness narrative from pearl harbor to hiroshima. Great tokyo air raid was a war crime the japan times. He returned to france in 1946 and published a book recounting his experiences. Mar 06, 2012 on march 9, 1945, b29 bombers in the u.
As with dropping the atomic bombs on hiroshima and nagasaki, the firebombing of tokyo has remained controversial since the end of world war ii. Strategic bombing and urban area bombing began in 1944 after the longrange b29 super fortress bomber entered service. The march 1945 firebombing of tokyo and the immorality of war. Mar 09, 2015 tokyo after the 1945 firebombing usaf. In the atomic bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki, the ussbs estimated that 125,000 japanese ci. As with dropping the atomic bombs on hiroshima and nagasaki, the firebombing of tokyo has remained. As explained in the history of the bombings, the united states created a set of nuclear bombs that were dropped on hiroshima and nagasaki only 6 months after severe firebombing. Tokyo wwii firebombing, the single most deadly bombing raid in. The city was almost entirely destroyed by august 1945, with 25% being destroyed in the march firebombing raid alone. More people died that night from napalm bombs than in the atomic strikes on hiroshima and nagasaki. The bombing of tokyo, tokyodaikushu was a series of firebombing air raids by. He is currently editing a book voices from the ashes on the firebombing.
Mar 09, 2015 an aerial armada of 334 b29 bombers took off from newly established bases in the mariana islands, bound for tokyo. Japan had wisely spread out its industrial facilities across tokyo so that one concerted attack could not deal a severe blow to its military capabilities. As a single mission, any conventional b29 mission would be cheaper than either of the atomic bombing missions. He was in tokyo on the night of march 9, 1945 when the wet winter weather made a surprise change to mild temperatures and gusty winds.
The story is written with the back and forth technique of the current status of ongoing bombing mission and the build up to the end of world war ii in the pacific theater. But the atomic bombing of hiroshima occurred just five days later, and toyamas tragic story was. The atomic bombing of hiroshima killed less japanese. Book summary on august 6, 1945, the first atomic bomb is dropped from an american plane on the 245,000 residents of hiroshima, japan. The nuclear attacks on hiroshima and nagasaki and the.
But im not sure that is comparing apples and apples. Jan 20, 2014 to my knowledge, there is no single statesponsored monument to the victims of the firebombing preserved for reflection or education in ways comparable to hiroshimas atomic dome, which was embraced not only by hiroshima and tokyo, but was also designated as a world heritage site. It was the highest death toll of any air raid during the war, including hiroshima and nagasaki. Aug 10, 20 robert guillain was a french reporter assigned to japan who was trapped in the country after japans attack on pearl harbor. Lindsay, cfrs senior vice president and director of studies, says the firebombing of tokyo should remind us of the destructive power of conventional weapons. The man who wont let the world forget the firebombing of. Searching for candor in a dreary, uncertain and dishonest. Japan surrendered six days after that, ending world war ii. The firebombing of tokyo did not lead to talk of surrender.
The bombing of tokyo often refers to a series of firebombing air raids by the united states army air forces during the pacific campaigns of world war ii. Recent research into archives shows that the japanese were not planning on surrender. He was in tokyo on the night of march 9, 1945 and published a book recounting his experiences, i saw tokyo burning. Mar 22, 2020 the firebombing of tokyo was an american bombing raid on the japanese city of tokyo which occurred on the night of 9 march, 1945. Jan 01, 2012 mission to tokyo this is the story of a firebombing raid of tokyo by boeing b29 bombers during the night of march 9 and 10, 1945. Saotome said he understood that hiroshima was unique in that it. Air force began dropping incendiary bombs on the city of tokyo. The physical, medical and social effects of the atomic bombing new york. News world asia tokyo fire bombing 70th anniversary. According to the us strategic bombing survey, conventional bombing of the japanese home islands killed 330,000 japanese civilians and wounded 476,000. It was the single most destructive bombing raid in history even more than the atomic bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki. Students will most likely be unfamiliar with the tokyo firebombing.
And the argument was that since hiroshima was not a special case, it did not warrant surrender. On 8 march lemay issued orders for a major firebombing attack on tokyo the next night. More people were killed in the indiscriminate firebombing of march 10 than in the immediate aftermath of the dropping of the atomic bomb on hiroshima. Operation meetinghouse, which was conducted on the night of 910 march 1945, is regarded as the single most destructive bombing raid in human history. The attacks on tokyo in march and then hiroshima and nagasaki in august 1945 remain the three most violent military operations conducted in modern human history. About 100,000 people died in the firebombing of tokyo in the summer of 1945, but that was conducted over several days and didnt involve atomic bombs. Mar 09, 2020 in 2018, fewer than 10,000 people, including groups of schoolchildren, visited the tokyo center, compared with the more than 1.
571 463 922 1470 1054 1042 542 257 1213 993 265 789 42 1272 587 489 743 196 1029 371 1351 1003 412 1438 954 1423 124 435 961 133 1106 1163 555 1063 244 301 645 1118 1153 150